Dictation and Transcription Apps: Where Spoken Notes End Up

A nurse practitioner finishes rounds and opens a free dictation app on her phone to speak her notes into it, because charting at the desk takes too long. The words appear on the screen as she talks. Where those words, and the audio behind them, actually go is something she has never seen.

Dictation and transcription tools are a real help to clinicians who are short on time. They also move spoken health information to a place you may not have chosen, so it is worth knowing where.

What happens when you speak

When you talk to a voice-to-text tool, one of two things usually happens. Some tools convert speech to text on the device itself. Many others send the audio over the internet to a service that processes it and returns the text. The service may keep the audio, the transcript or both, for a period of time that you may not know. Some providers use stored recordings to improve their products unless you opt out.

A tool built into a phone, a web browser, a meeting app or a free app can behave quite differently from one purchased for clinical use under a contract. From the outside, they look identical.

Why it matters in care settings

A dictated note may contain a resident's name, diagnosis, medications and family situation. That is protected health information, and a company that stores or processes it for you is generally handling it on your behalf. Under HIPAA, that normally calls for a written agreement with the vendor, known as a Business Associate Agreement. Whether a particular tool qualifies, and what you need, is a question for your privacy officer or counsel.

Staff often adopt convenient tools without asking. A manager who knows what to ask can head off a quiet problem.

Questions to ask before approving a tool

Put these to the vendor, in writing, and keep the answers.

Is the audio processed on the device or sent to the vendor's servers?

Where are recordings and transcripts stored, and in which country?

How long are they kept, and can we set the period or delete them on request?

Is the data used to train or improve the product? Can that be turned off?

Who at the vendor can access our recordings?

Will the vendor sign a Business Associate Agreement?

Is the data encrypted while traveling and while stored?

Does the tool let us manage accounts centrally, so we can remove access when someone leaves?

What happens to our data if we cancel?

If a vendor will not answer these plainly, that tells you something.

Check where the files land

Even a well-chosen tool can create stray copies. Look at the whole path:

Does the app save audio on the phone, where it may sit in a camera roll or a backup?

Do transcripts sync to a personal cloud account?

Are notes pasted into email or a text message to move them to the chart?

Does the tool keep a history that other users of a shared device can open?

The safest design lets the clinician dictate directly into your EHR or an approved tool and keeps nothing elsewhere.

Guidance for managers

Do not rely on a blanket ban, because staff who need a faster way to chart will find one. Offer an approved option instead.

Name the tool or tools that are approved and put that in writing.

Tell staff plainly that free consumer apps and built-in assistants are not approved for resident details unless cleared.

Provide a quick way to ask: a person staff can message before trying something new.

Review what is actually in use, perhaps by asking in a staff meeting what people dictate with.

Include dictation in your risk review, and let your insurer know if they ask about technology tools.

Other speech in the building

The same questions apply to voice assistants, smart speakers, meeting transcription features and recording features on phones. If a device is listening in a resident's room or at the nurse station, someone should know where the audio goes.

How we can help

UnityCare IT helps clinicians and administrators vet voice-to-text and transcription tools, including drafting the vendor questions and making sure approved tools are configured and managed. We work with your privacy officer on Business Associate Agreements and can help move staff from unapproved apps to ones you can stand behind.

Related service

Security monitoring, HIPAA safeguards, backups and staff training for healthcare and small businesses.

Related articles

Keep reading

Contact UnityCare Technologies

Call or text: 405-285-3845

New customers: start@unitycareit.com

Existing customers: support@unitycareit.com

Service area: based in Edmond, Oklahoma, serving Oklahoma, Texas and Kansas

Hours: Mon–Fri 8 AM–5 PM CT; 24/7 after-hours support