Cyber insurance requirements: what underwriters ask for

Most cyber insurers want to see multi-factor authentication, managed endpoint protection, tested backups, email filtering, staff training and a written incident response plan. Answer the application truthfully, because a wrong answer can cause trouble at claim time.

Cyber insurance applications used to be a page long. Now they read like a security audit. Underwriters have learned which controls keep a bad day from turning into a large claim, and they ask about them directly.

This guide explains the common questions in plain terms. It is general information, not legal or insurance advice. Every carrier is different, so confirm the specifics with your agent or broker and read your own policy.

Who needs to pay attention

Any organization that buys or renews a cyber policy. That covers far more than technology companies. Clinics, nursing homes, law offices, contractors, nonprofits and retailers are all asked the same kinds of questions.

You may also face these requirements indirectly. A lender, a landlord, a large customer or a healthcare partner may require you to carry cyber coverage, which means you have to qualify for it.

What underwriters commonly ask for

The exact list varies by carrier and by the size of your organization, but the same controls come up again and again.

Multi-factor authentication (MFA)

Usually the first question. Insurers want MFA on email, on remote access such as VPN or remote desktop, and on administrator accounts. Read the wording closely. Many forms ask if MFA is on for all users, and a few exceptions mean the honest answer is no.

Endpoint detection and response (EDR)

This is the modern replacement for basic antivirus. It watches computers and servers for suspicious behavior, and someone reviews the alerts. Insurers often ask if it is installed on every device, servers included.

Backups that are tested

Expect questions about how often you back up, where copies are kept, whether one copy is offline or cannot be altered by an attacker, and when you last tested a restore. A backup nobody has restored from is a hope, not a control.

Email filtering

Most attacks arrive by email. Carriers ask about filtering for malicious links and attachments, and sometimes about the domain records that make your email harder to impersonate.

Security awareness training

Insurers want to know that staff are trained to spot phishing and that the training repeats. Some ask about simulated phishing tests and about how you verify a request to change payment details.

A written incident response plan

A short document that says who to call, who decides, and what to do in the first hours of an incident. It should include your insurer's claim line, because many policies expect you to call them early.

Answering the questionnaire truthfully

The application is part of your contract with the insurer. If an answer turns out to be wrong, the carrier may dispute or reduce a claim, or cancel the policy. That is the risk of checking yes on a control you only partly have.

A few habits keep you out of trouble. Do not guess. If the person signing does not know the answer, ask whoever runs your IT. Read qualifiers such as all, every and always literally. Where the honest answer is partly, say so and explain in the comments or through your broker. Keep a copy of what you submitted and the evidence behind each answer.

An honest no is not the end of the conversation. Carriers will sometimes offer coverage with conditions, or give you time to fix a gap. A plan with dates is far better than a wrong answer.

Evidence to have ready

You will not always be asked for proof at application time, but you will want it after an incident. Gather it once and keep it current.

Common gaps we find before renewal

How an IT provider helps, and what stays with you

A good IT provider can translate each question, tell you plainly which controls you have today, put the missing ones in place before renewal, and produce the reports that back up your answers. Start early. Rolling out MFA or replacing a backup system the week before renewal is stressful for everyone.

The application itself is still yours. Someone at your organization signs it and is responsible for its accuracy. Coverage decisions, limits and exclusions belong with you and your broker. And no IT provider can promise that you will be approved, that a claim will be paid, or that an attack will never get through. Controls lower the odds and limit the damage. They do not remove the risk.

Common questions

Can we get cyber insurance without MFA? It depends on the carrier, but it is getting harder. Many insurers treat MFA on email and remote access as a baseline, and those that do not may charge more or limit coverage. Ask your broker what your carrier expects.

Is antivirus the same as EDR? No. Traditional antivirus mainly looks for known bad files. EDR watches behavior, records what happened and lets someone respond. If the form asks for EDR, check with your IT provider before answering yes.

Who should fill out the application? Usually a leader at your organization signs it, with the technical answers supplied by whoever manages your IT. Do it together. The signer should understand what each yes means.

What if something changes after we apply? Tell your broker. If a control you reported is turned off or a major system changes, ask how your policy treats that. Do not wait until renewal.

Renewal coming up?

Send us your questionnaire. We will explain what each question is asking, tell you honestly where you stand, and help close the gaps before you sign. Call or text 405-285-3845.

Related reading

Contact UnityCare Technologies

Call or text: 405-285-3845

New customers: start@unitycareit.com

Existing customers: support@unitycareit.com

Service area: based in Edmond, Oklahoma, serving Oklahoma, Texas and Kansas

Hours: Mon–Fri 8 AM–5 PM CT; 24/7 after-hours support