A resident's daughter stops at the front desk and says, quietly, that her aunt told a neighbor about her mother's cancer, and the aunt only knew because someone on the staff called her. She is angry, and she wants to know who. The receptionist says she will "let somebody know" and the daughter leaves.
What happens in the next few days decides whether this stays a conversation or becomes a formal complaint to a regulator. HIPAA requires you to have a process for people to complain about your privacy practices. A good process also resolves most concerns, fairly and early.
A covered organization must give people a way to file a complaint about its privacy policies or its compliance with them, name a contact person or office to receive complaints, and document the complaints it receives and what happened. Your notice of privacy practices should say how to complain, including that a person may also complain directly to the federal government, and that you will not retaliate. You cannot require someone to give up their right to complain as a condition of care.
A complaint should not have to start with a form. Residents and families raise concerns at the bedside, at care plan meetings and at the front desk. Train every staff member to do three things when they hear one:
Listen without arguing or explaining.
Write down what was said, who said it, and when.
Pass it to the privacy official the same day, and tell the person you have done so.
Provide a simple written option as well, with the privacy official's name and a way to send it privately, and help anyone who needs assistance filling it out.
Think of it in five stages.
Receive. Log the complaint with date, complainant, resident, a short description and who took it. Acknowledge it promptly, in writing if possible, and say when they can expect an answer.
Triage. The privacy official decides whether it is a privacy matter, a possible breach, a care concern or a billing question. Care and quality concerns go to the right department as well. If it may be a breach, start your incident process right away and involve counsel or your insurer as your policy says.
Investigate. Gather facts. Who had access? What do the audit logs show about who opened the chart? Interview staff separately and ask open questions. Look at the policy that applies, and whether it was followed. Preserve emails, logs and notes. Avoid having anyone who is the subject of the complaint investigate it.
Respond. Write to the complainant in plain language. Say what you looked at, what you found at a level appropriate to the privacy of others, and what you are doing about it. You may not be able to share personnel actions, and you should say so. Offer a call or a meeting.
Close and learn. Record the outcome. If a policy was broken, apply your sanctions policy consistently. If the policy was unclear, fix it. If a system allowed too much access, change it.
Treating a complaint as an attack. Most people are trying to protect a person they love.
Waiting for the complainant to put it in writing before acting.
Letting the person named in the complaint handle it.
Telling the complainant too much about another resident or a staff member.
Saying "there was no violation" before you have checked the access logs.
Forgetting the no-retaliation rule. Staff must not treat the family or resident differently afterward.
Keep the complaint, any notes, the audit logs you reviewed, interview summaries, your response, and the outcome and corrective steps. HIPAA expects documentation to be retained for a required period. Ask your counsel or privacy officer how long applies to your organization, and keep these records in a restricted location.
Call counsel or your insurer if the complaint threatens a lawsuit, alleges a serious breach, involves a regulator already, or involves a staff member who may have acted deliberately. A prompt, well-documented internal response will also help if the matter later does reach an agency.
UnityCare IT helps with the evidence side of a complaint: pulling access and audit logs from your EHR and Microsoft 365, preserving email and files, and storing the complaint file securely. We provide HIPAA-aware support, sign Business Associate Agreements, and work with your privacy officer and counsel.
Security monitoring, HIPAA safeguards, backups and staff training for healthcare and small businesses.
Call or text: 405-285-3845
New customers: start@unitycareit.com
Existing customers: support@unitycareit.com
Service area: based in Edmond, Oklahoma, serving Oklahoma, Texas and Kansas
Hours: Mon–Fri 8 AM–5 PM CT; 24/7 after-hours support