Protecting Employee Files: Social Security Numbers in HR Systems

An HR director is asked for a list of employees with their hire dates for a state report. She opens the old spreadsheet she has used for years. It has a column for Social Security numbers, because it started as an onboarding checklist. She emails it to a colleague, who saves it to the desktop. Now there are three copies, and only one was meant to exist.

Employee identity data spreads quietly. Each copy is another place where it can be lost, stolen or seen by someone who has no need. The aim of this article is to find where the data gathers in a typical facility and to reduce it.

Where Social Security numbers collect

Walk through a new hire's paperwork and note every place their number appears. The usual list looks like this:

The payroll system and the HR or applicant system.

Scanned I-9 documents, W-4 forms and copies of Social Security cards and driver's licenses on the office scanner or in a scanned-documents folder.

Spreadsheets for onboarding, license tracking, background checks, training rosters or benefits enrollment.

The email sent and received folders, especially messages with attachments to the payroll company, insurance broker or background check vendor.

A shared network drive with a folder named "HR" that many people can open.

Paper in the personnel file, in a desk drawer or in a box in a closet.

The scanner or copier itself, which may keep scanned images on its hard drive or in a scan-to-email queue.

Laptops, USB sticks and personal phones.

You will not find everything on the first pass. Start with the places that are easiest to search.

Decide what you really need to keep

For each place, ask two questions. Do we still need this, and who needs it? If a spreadsheet only needs names and hire dates, the number should not be there. If a scan is a duplicate of something stored in the payroll system, one of them can go. Retention rules for personnel records depend on federal and state law and on your insurance and payer requirements, so confirm timelines with your attorney or state association before you destroy anything. Keep legally required records, and remove the unnecessary copies.

Reduce the copies

Once you know what to keep, take practical steps:

Remove Social Security number columns from working spreadsheets. If a number is needed in a report, use the last four digits.

Search shared drives and the HR mailbox for files and messages that include the numbers, and move the necessary ones into a single restricted location.

Stop scanning identity documents to a general folder. Configure the scanner to send to a named person or a restricted folder, and delete the scan from the device after.

Delete old spreadsheets from desktops, Downloads folders and USB drives, after confirming they are copies.

Ask vendors to use their secure portals rather than email attachments.

Lock down what remains

The records you keep should sit in one controlled place, ideally the HR or payroll system, with a restricted folder in SharePoint or on your file server for anything else. Give access to named people in HR and payroll and nobody else, not "everyone in the office." Turn on multi-factor authentication for the HR and payroll systems and for the email accounts of the people who use them. Make sure laptops that might hold these files are encrypted and locked with a password. Paper files should be in a locked cabinet, with a short list of people holding the key.

Set a simple rule for staff

Tell HR and office staff what to do when an employee emails their own Social Security number, which happens often. They should move it to the proper place and delete the message, and then politely ask the employee to use the secure method next time. Write it down so it does not depend on one person's memory.

Review once a year

Pick one day each year to repeat the search. Check who can open the HR folders, whether former staff still have access and whether any new spreadsheets have grown a Social Security column. Include shredding or secure disposal of paper you are allowed to destroy.

How we can help

UnityCare IT can search your shared drives and mailboxes for places where identity data has collected, set up a restricted and logged location for HR files, and configure scanners to stop leaving copies behind. We can also encrypt laptops and turn on multi-factor authentication for the people who work with this data.

Related service

Security monitoring, HIPAA safeguards, backups and staff training for healthcare and small businesses.

Related articles

Keep reading

Contact UnityCare Technologies

Call or text: 405-285-3845

New customers: start@unitycareit.com

Existing customers: support@unitycareit.com

Service area: based in Edmond, Oklahoma, serving Oklahoma, Texas and Kansas

Hours: Mon–Fri 8 AM–5 PM CT; 24/7 after-hours support