An envelope arrives by certified mail addressed to the administrator. Inside is a letter on law firm stationery asking for a former resident's complete chart, along with a page headed "Subpoena." The person who opens it in medical records sees the word and feels the urge to comply. That urge is the thing to resist until a few questions have been answered.
Three kinds of requests tend to get lumped together: a court order, a subpoena and a letter from an attorney. HIPAA treats them differently, and mixing them up is a common way for a facility to disclose records it should not have.
A court order is signed by a judge. It directs you to produce specific information. HIPAA permits you to disclose what the order expressly authorizes, and nothing beyond it.
A subpoena is a demand for records or testimony, often issued by an attorney or a court clerk in connection with a case. Many subpoenas are not signed by a judge. On its own, an ordinary subpoena does not automatically allow you to release health information.
An attorney's letter or records request is just a request. It may be from the resident's own lawyer, a family member's lawyer, an insurer's lawyer or the lawyer for the other side of a dispute. It has no legal force to compel you. It may be accompanied by an authorization signed by the resident, which is a different matter.
When a subpoena or discovery request is not accompanied by a court order, HIPAA permits disclosure only if you receive satisfactory assurances from the party seeking the information. In general terms, those are either:
Written proof that reasonable efforts were made to notify the resident, and that the time to object has passed with no objection or the objection has been resolved.
Written proof that the parties have agreed to a qualified protective order, or have asked a court for one.
Without one of these, you should not release the records. You may also choose to give the resident notice yourself. Because the details are easy to misapply, involve your attorney before responding.
Log it. Record the date received and who received it, and route it to the privacy officer and the administrator the same day. Subpoenas often carry response dates, and the clock matters. Counsel should set the plan quickly.
Read the document. Who issued it? Is there a judge's signature or a court seal? What case does it refer to? What exactly does it request?
Verify the sender. Call the court or the law firm using a number you looked up yourself, not the one on the letter.
Look for an authorization. If the resident or their personal representative signed a valid HIPAA authorization, check that it covers the requesting party and the records requested.
Check the resident's status. A living resident, a deceased resident and a minor each raise different questions.
Look at the type of records. Substance use disorder treatment records and mental health notes may carry stronger protections than the regular chart. Do not assume the same rules apply.
Call your attorney. Have counsel review the document and decide whether to produce, object or seek a protective order.
If counsel approves release, send the narrowest set that satisfies the order. If the request asks for a date range, give that date range. Do not send the full chart because it is easier. Keep a copy of exactly what was sent, with a transmittal letter that lists it, and use a secure delivery method instead of unencrypted email or a standard fax if possible.
You may also be asked for a records custodian certification. That should come from the person your counsel designates.
Disclosures made under a subpoena or court order are generally ones that must be logged for the resident's accounting of disclosures. Note the date, the recipient, what was sent and the basis for release.
Process servers and attorneys' couriers sometimes arrive at the front desk. Staff should accept the paper politely, note the time, and pass it to the administrator at once. They should not hand over records on the spot, and they should not discuss whether a person is or was a resident.
State law adds many wrinkles here, including rules on confidentiality, discovery and notice. Check with your attorney. This article is not legal advice.
UnityCare IT can help you find and export the right records quickly from your EHR and shared drives, set up secure delivery for what you send, and preserve information with proper backups. We offer HIPAA-aware support with signed Business Associate Agreements, working with care providers across Oklahoma, Texas and Kansas.
Security monitoring, HIPAA safeguards, backups and staff training for healthcare and small businesses.
Call or text: 405-285-3845
New customers: start@unitycareit.com
Existing customers: support@unitycareit.com
Service area: based in Edmond, Oklahoma, serving Oklahoma, Texas and Kansas
Hours: Mon–Fri 8 AM–5 PM CT; 24/7 after-hours support