The email arrives in the payroll coordinator's inbox early in the year. It appears to come from the administrator or the owner, and it is short: "Please send me copies of all employee W-2s as PDFs. I need them for the accountant. Reply here, I'm in a meeting." The tone is hurried and familiar. The coordinator wants to be helpful.
That email is a well-known scam. It targets HR, payroll and the business office because those people hold the forms. One reply can hand a criminal the names, addresses and Social Security numbers of every employee, who may then file false tax returns in their names. This article gives you a procedure staff can follow without feeling rude.
The scammers change the wording, but the pattern is steady:
The sender's display name is a real executive, owner or administrator. The actual email address is often a lookalike or an unrelated account.
The request is for all employees, a full list or "the payroll file," not one person's form.
It stresses urgency or says the sender is unavailable by phone.
It asks for a reply with attachments, or for a link to a shared folder.
It often arrives in a lull, such as early in the morning, on a Friday afternoon or while the administrator is traveling.
Sometimes the first message is just "Are you at your desk?" The question is a probe. If someone answers, the second message makes the real request.
The most effective control is a plain policy that applies to everyone, including the owner: no one sends employee W-2s, payroll registers or lists with Social Security numbers by email on the strength of an email request. Put it in writing, and have the administrator say aloud that it applies to them. When the rule is universal, staff are not refusing the boss, they are following the boss's own policy.
Give HR and payroll staff a short script they can follow every time:
Do not reply to the email and do not click any link.
Contact the requester using a phone number or method you already had, such as their desk line or in person, not one from the email.
Ask what the files are for and who exactly will receive them.
If the request is real, use the approved method, such as the payroll provider's secure portal or a restricted shared folder with named recipients.
Report the original message to IT or whoever manages email, and then delete it.
Staff should know they will never be in trouble for asking, even if the request turns out to be real. A real executive will appreciate the caution.
Speed matters. Tell the administrator and your IT provider immediately and do not wait to see what happens. You will need to figure out which records were sent and whether they included Social Security numbers. Your counsel or compliance officer can advise on notifying affected employees and any agencies, because the rules vary by state and by circumstance. Employees may want to consider placing fraud alerts or credit freezes, and the IRS and state tax agencies have processes for identity theft. Your payroll provider and your insurer can also tell you what steps they expect.
People send files by email when the proper route is slow. Make sure the payroll provider's portal lets the accountant download forms directly, or set up a secure shared folder with named access for the CPA. When the safe way is the easy way, the unsafe request stands out.
Look at who can see the W-2 files. If every office employee has access to the whole folder, a compromised mailbox leaks everything. Limit access to those who need it, and see our related guidance on storing employee identity data. Also consider turning on warning banners for email from outside your organization, which helps staff see that a message pretending to be the administrator did not come from inside.
UnityCare IT can set up external-sender banners, stronger filtering and impersonation protections for your Microsoft 365 email, and we can help you create a secure way to share payroll documents with your accountant. We can also train HR and payroll staff to spot this particular request and respond quickly if one gets through.
Security monitoring, HIPAA safeguards, backups and staff training for healthcare and small businesses.
Call or text: 405-285-3845
New customers: start@unitycareit.com
Existing customers: support@unitycareit.com
Service area: based in Edmond, Oklahoma, serving Oklahoma, Texas and Kansas
Hours: Mon–Fri 8 AM–5 PM CT; 24/7 after-hours support