Writing a HIPAA Sanction Policy With Consistent Discipline Levels

Two aides look at the same chart without a reason. One is a nurse who has worked in your building for fifteen years and is well liked. The other started three weeks ago. If the first gets a quiet talking-to and the second gets fired, you do not have a sanction policy. You have a mood.

HIPAA requires you to have sanctions for workforce members who fail to follow your privacy and security policies, and to document what you do. The rule does not tell you what the sanctions should be. That part is yours to write, and the value is in writing it before you need it, so that discipline is applied the same way no matter who is involved.

Start with what the policy has to say

The policy should name who it covers (employees, agency staff, volunteers, students, contractors who work under your direction), what it covers (your privacy and security policies, not just the law), and who decides. It should also say that sanctions apply whether or not harm resulted, and that the policy does not apply to someone who reports a concern in good faith or files a complaint. Staff who fear punishment for reporting will stop reporting.

Keep the language plain. Your policy will be read by a director of nursing at 6 a.m., not only by a lawyer.

Build violation levels around intent and impact

Most facilities find three or four levels are enough. A common way to sort them is by whether the act was accidental, careless or deliberate, and by how much exposure it created. For example:

Level one, unintentional or careless: leaving a screen unlocked, discussing a resident in a hallway where others could hear, sending a document to the wrong internal person.

Level two, repeated or knowing disregard of a rule: sharing a password, taking a chart photo "for convenience," ignoring retraining after a first level one event.

Level three, intentional or for personal gain: looking up a neighbor, ex-spouse or coworker without a work reason, selling or posting information, taking records to a new employer.

Give each level a range of consequences instead of a single outcome, such as retraining and a documented coaching conversation at the low end, and suspension or termination at the high end. A range lets you account for circumstances while still keeping a floor and a ceiling. Have your attorney or HR advisor review the ranges, because employment law differs by state and may affect how you can apply them.

Spell out the factors you will weigh

Within a level, decisions should rest on written factors, not on who the person is. Useful factors include whether the act was intentional, whether the person had been trained on that specific rule, whether it was a first or repeat event, whether the person was honest and quick to report, how sensitive the information was, and whether anyone was harmed or exposed.

Write the factors down and then use them. When you later explain a decision to a surveyor, an investigator or an employment lawyer, a list of factors you actually applied is far stronger than a vague policy.

Make it the same for the administrator and the aide

The hardest test of a sanction policy is the person you do not want to discipline: the top-performing nurse, the long-time maintenance director, a physician with referrals, a board member's relative. Decide now that rank does not change the level. If someone in leadership breaks the rule, the privacy officer and HR apply the same process, and a person who is the subject of an investigation should not be the one deciding the outcome.

Document every event and keep the record

Each sanction decision should leave a short record: what happened, which policy was broken, the level assigned, the factors considered, the outcome, who decided, and the date. Keep these records with your HIPAA documentation, separate from general personnel notes if you can, and retain them according to your counsel's advice and your state's rules.

A simple review step helps. Once or twice a year, have the privacy officer and HR look across all recent cases and ask whether similar acts got similar results. If they did not, fix the policy or the practice.

Steps to put this in place

Pull your current policy, or confirm you have one.

Define three or four levels with examples drawn from your own building.

Attach a range of consequences to each level, reviewed by counsel or HR.

List the factors decision makers must weigh.

Name who decides and who is excluded when they are personally involved.

Add the policy to new hire orientation and have staff acknowledge it.

Use one incident form every time, even for small events.

How we can help

UnityCare IT helps care providers build the technical side that makes a sanction policy enforceable, such as individual logins, access logs and alerts that show who opened which record. We can pull those reports for your privacy officer when an incident needs to be reviewed, and our HIPAA-aware team can help you line your written policies up with how your systems actually work.

Related service

Security monitoring, HIPAA safeguards, backups and staff training for healthcare and small businesses.

Related articles

Keep reading

Contact UnityCare Technologies

Call or text: 405-285-3845

New customers: start@unitycareit.com

Existing customers: support@unitycareit.com

Service area: based in Edmond, Oklahoma, serving Oklahoma, Texas and Kansas

Hours: Mon–Fri 8 AM–5 PM CT; 24/7 after-hours support