On the Monday that open enrollment begins, a CNA gets two messages. One is from HR with the real instructions. The other says "ACTION REQUIRED: Confirm your benefits by Friday or lose coverage," with a button that leads to a page asking for her Social Security number and date of birth. She has just worked a double and she is not sure which one is real.
Enrollment season is predictable, which makes it a gift to scammers. Employees are expecting an email, they are rushed and they care about their health coverage. HR leaders can reduce the risk by doing two things: warn staff in advance and make the real process unmistakable.
The messages vary, but they share patterns. They may claim to come from HR, the insurance carrier, the benefits administrator or "the payroll department." They create urgency, threatening loss of coverage or a missed deadline. They ask the reader to click a link and sign in, or to provide personal information to "verify" enrollment. The page behind the link is built to capture a username and password or identity details.
Staff who work nights, weekends or at several locations are often reading these messages on a phone, where the sender address and link destination are harder to see. Many aides and housekeepers do not have a work email at all, and are being contacted through personal accounts or text messages, so a warning only sent to the work inbox will miss them.
Send a short, plain message two weeks before enrollment opens. Include:
The dates enrollment will run.
The exact way real instructions will reach staff, for example "a letter in your pay envelope, a posting in the break room and one email from hr at our official address."
A clear statement of what HR will never do, such as ask for a Social Security number by email, text or phone, or ask for a password.
Who to call or visit when a message looks wrong.
Post the same notice on the break room board and read it aloud at a shift huddle. People who skip email will still hear it.
Impostors win when real messages look vague. Give the real process a consistent look:
Use one sender, one subject format and one location for the enrollment page every year.
Tell people to type the web address from the printed notice or to go through the intranet or employee portal, not to click links in messages.
Hold in-person enrollment sessions or help hours on each shift, where staff can ask questions and enroll with someone beside them.
Give every employee a printed one-page guide with a phone number and a named HR contact.
If your benefits administrator sends messages directly, tell staff in advance the name they will see.
Staff need a low-effort way to ask, "Is this real?" Set up a shared mailbox or a phone extension that gets a quick answer, and say plainly that asking is welcome. Encourage them to forward suspicious messages to that address instead of replying. A manager who laughs it off or ignores a question teaches people to guess, so ask supervisors to treat it seriously.
Tell HR and your IT provider about any employee who enters a password or personal information on a suspicious page. Change the password right away, check for other accounts using the same one and watch the employee's identity information. If many employees report the same message, send a quick follow-up to everyone confirming it is fake. Your benefits broker or the carrier may also want to know, since impostors often use their name.
Your real enrollment portal, payroll system and email accounts should require multi-factor authentication. Check with your benefits administrator about how employees sign in and whether anyone can see changes to bank details or beneficiary information. Changes made during enrollment week deserve extra attention.
UnityCare IT can help your HR team set up email filtering and external-sender warnings in Microsoft 365, turn on multi-factor authentication for staff accounts and review what your real enrollment emails look like to the people who receive them. We can also help you create a plain-language staff warning and a simple place for employees to report suspicious messages.
Security monitoring, HIPAA safeguards, backups and staff training for healthcare and small businesses.
Call or text: 405-285-3845
New customers: start@unitycareit.com
Existing customers: support@unitycareit.com
Service area: based in Edmond, Oklahoma, serving Oklahoma, Texas and Kansas
Hours: Mon–Fri 8 AM–5 PM CT; 24/7 after-hours support