Unemployment Claim Fraud Filed Under Your Employees Names

A dietary aide who has worked for you for two years mentions at the time clock that she got a letter from the state about unemployment benefits. She has not lost her job. Around the same time, your business office manager finds a notice addressed to the facility about a "former employee" that makes no sense. That pairing is the typical way unemployment claim fraud shows up.

Criminals use stolen personal information to file for unemployment in someone else's name. They often pick employers with large workforces and then wait for the benefits to be paid. The employee may not know until a letter or a tax form arrives. HR and the business office are often the first to see the signs, and a calm, quick response protects both the employee and the facility.

What the notices look like

The agency sends your facility a notice or request for information when a claim names you as an employer. The exact form varies by state, but common clues that a claim is fraudulent include:

The named person is still working for you, or never worked for you.

The reason given for separation does not match anything that occurred.

The employee gets a debit card, a letter or a benefit statement they did not request.

The notice arrives at an odd time, such as a flurry of notices for several employees at once.

The employee finds a claim when trying to file their own for a real layoff.

Also be wary of emails or texts claiming to be from the state unemployment agency that ask you or an employee to click a link to "verify" a claim. Use the official agency website or phone number you look up yourself.

What to do for the employee

Treat the employee as a victim, not a suspect. Steps you can offer:

Tell them calmly that this has happened to other employers and that they did nothing wrong.

Explain that they should report the fraud to the state unemployment agency, usually through a fraud reporting page or phone line on its official site.

Suggest they review their credit reports, consider a fraud alert or credit freeze, and watch for other misuse of their identity.

Point them to the federal government's identity theft reporting resources and to the IRS, since a false claim can lead to a tax form showing income they did not receive. The agency's own materials will explain the process.

Offer a private place and time at work to make the calls, and ask whether the employee wants help from your HR or benefits contact.

If the employee received benefits they did not request, they should not spend or return them without guidance from the agency.

What to do for the agency

Respond to the notice by the deadline stated on it, and give accurate facts: the person is still employed, or was never employed. Keep copies of what you sent and a note of who you spoke to. Report the suspected fraud to the agency using its fraud process, and ask whether it wants additional information. If you are charged for benefits improperly, ask the agency how to dispute the charge. Your attorney, your state association or your unemployment tax advisor can tell you what the rules require in your state.

Ask how the identity was obtained

The fraud may start with a breach somewhere else, but check your own house. Review who has access to employee Social Security numbers, whether staff recently received phishing emails, and whether payroll or HR files were sent by email or exposed. If several employees were named at once, tell your IT provider and your counsel, because a leak of an employee list may require a closer look. You can read our related guidance on W-2 request scams and on protecting identity data in HR files.

Build a short checklist

Keep a one-page procedure in the HR office: who receives state notices, who checks them against the current employee list, who contacts the employee, and who responds to the agency. Route all unemployment mail to one person so it does not sit in a general mailbox.

How we can help

UnityCare IT can help you check whether employee data was exposed through your email or file systems, tighten access to HR records and set up protections that make impersonation of your staff harder. If you believe a breach of your systems may have played a role, we can help you gather the facts your counsel will need.

Related service

Security monitoring, HIPAA safeguards, backups and staff training for healthcare and small businesses.

Related articles

Keep reading

Contact UnityCare Technologies

Call or text: 405-285-3845

New customers: start@unitycareit.com

Existing customers: support@unitycareit.com

Service area: based in Edmond, Oklahoma, serving Oklahoma, Texas and Kansas

Hours: Mon–Fri 8 AM–5 PM CT; 24/7 after-hours support