Biometric Time Clocks: Handling Fingerprint Data Responsibly

The new time clock in the break room scans an aide's finger and logs her in. It solves a real problem: buddy punching, where one employee clocks in for another. It also means your facility is now collecting biometric data, a kind of information that cannot be changed the way a password can.

If you run a facility in Texas, or you have employees there, there are specific rules to know. This article explains what these systems store, what questions to settle with the vendor and your staff, and where to get legal guidance. It is not legal advice.

What the clock actually stores

Most modern clocks do not keep a picture of a fingerprint or a face. They convert the scan into a mathematical template, a string of numbers used to match a future scan. That is better than a stored image, but the template is still tied to a person's body, and it can still be sensitive if the system is breached. Ask your vendor to explain in plain terms:

Whether the system stores an image, a template or both.

Where the data lives: on the device, on your own server or in the vendor's cloud.

Whether the data is encrypted when stored and when traveling between the clock and the server.

Who at the vendor can see or export it.

What happens to an employee's template when they leave.

Texas and other states

Texas has a state law about the capture and use of biometric identifiers, and it generally requires notice to the person and their consent before collecting, limits on selling or sharing the data, reasonable care in storing it and destruction within a set period after the purpose ends. Several other states have their own rules, and some have stricter ones. Oklahoma and Kansas rules differ from Texas, and the rules continue to change. The details matter and an error would be costly, so they are not spelled out here. Have your attorney review the current requirements for each state where you have employees, and confirm what your vendor contract says about compliance.

Questions to settle before you use biometrics

Work through these with your administrator, HR director and legal counsel:

Notice and consent. How will you tell employees what is collected and why, and how will you record that they agreed? A signed form is common.

Alternatives. Will staff who object, or who have injuries or skin conditions that make scanning unreliable, be able to use a badge or PIN?

Purpose. Will you use the data only for time and attendance, and commit in writing not to use it for anything else?

Retention. When will the template be deleted after an employee leaves, and who will confirm it happened?

Sharing. Does the vendor share, sell or use the data for other purposes? Your contract should say no.

Breach. What will the vendor do and tell you if its systems are compromised?

Protect the system itself

Treat the clock and its software like any other system holding sensitive data. Use a strong administrator password, give only HR or payroll the rights to view or export employee records, and turn on multi-factor authentication if the cloud portal supports it. Keep the clock's software updated, and put the device on a network separate from your resident-care and office systems when you can. Do not leave a spare management laptop connected to the clock unattended in a shared area.

Plan for the end of the relationship

When you change vendors or stop using biometrics, ask for written confirmation that the vendor deleted your employees' data and that backups are covered. Do the same for departing employees on a regular schedule, for example when HR completes the termination checklist. This is where many facilities slip, because deletion is not anyone's job until you assign it.

Weigh the alternative

For some facilities, a badge or a PIN with a camera at the clock or a manager's review of exceptions is enough to deter buddy punching, with less legal and security burden. Biometrics may still be the right choice, but it should be a decision you made on purpose with the facts in hand.

How we can help

UnityCare IT can review how your time clock system is set up, who can see employee records, how data is encrypted and how the device sits on your network. We can also help you ask your vendor the right questions, and we leave the legal conclusions to your attorney.

Related service

Security monitoring, HIPAA safeguards, backups and staff training for healthcare and small businesses.

Related articles

Keep reading

Contact UnityCare Technologies

Call or text: 405-285-3845

New customers: start@unitycareit.com

Existing customers: support@unitycareit.com

Service area: based in Edmond, Oklahoma, serving Oklahoma, Texas and Kansas

Hours: Mon–Fri 8 AM–5 PM CT; 24/7 after-hours support