A resident's son arrives at the administrator's office with a signed request for his mother's records. The administrator is worried. The chart contains notes about a family dispute and some difficult behavior. Her first instinct is to say no. The rule says that instinct needs to be tested against a short, specific list of reasons.
HIPAA starts from the position that a resident has a right to inspect and obtain a copy of the records in their designated record set. Refusal is the exception, and the exceptions are narrower than most staff expect.
Several reasons staff commonly give do not allow a denial under the federal rule:
The resident owes the facility money.
The record contains information the resident will find upsetting.
The facility created the record, so it feels it belongs to the facility.
The request is inconvenient, or the resident is difficult.
The resident is asking for the records in order to sue or complain.
Some of these may be handled by other means. A fee for copying is allowed within the rules, for example, but withholding the record because a bill is unpaid is not. If you are unsure, assume the answer is to provide access and ask your privacy officer to check.
A few situations allow denial without the resident having a right to ask for a review. In general terms, they include:
Psychotherapy notes, which are kept separate from the regular record.
Information compiled for use in a legal proceeding, or in anticipation of one.
Certain laboratory results, where the law governing the lab limits access.
Records of an inmate, where access would threaten safety.
Information obtained from someone other than a health care provider under a promise of confidentiality, where access would reveal the source.
Records held for research, where the resident agreed to temporary denial.
If only part of a record falls into one of these categories, you must give access to the rest.
Other grounds exist, and in these cases the resident can ask for review. They arise when a licensed health care professional decides, using professional judgment, that:
Access is reasonably likely to endanger the life or physical safety of the resident or someone else.
The record refers to another person (not a health care provider) and access is reasonably likely to cause substantial harm to that person.
A request made by a personal representative would likely cause substantial harm to the resident or another person.
These are judgments by a licensed professional, not by the administrator or the business office. The decision should be written down with its reasoning. If the resident asks for a review, a different licensed professional, one who was not involved in the original decision, must carry it out and the facility must follow that person's conclusion.
A denial must be in writing, in plain language, and sent within the timeframe the rule sets. Check the current timing with counsel. The letter should include:
The basis for the denial, in terms the resident can follow.
If the ground allows review, an explanation of the right to review and how to request it.
How to file a complaint with the facility and with the federal Office for Civil Rights, with the name or title and phone number of your contact person.
If you hold only part of the record being asked for and know where the rest is, a note saying where the resident might ask.
Give the resident access to everything not covered by the denial, even if it means redacting a few lines.
Log the request with the date received and the name of the requester.
Verify identity and authority, especially for someone acting for the resident.
Review the record for anything that might fit a ground for denial.
Have the licensed professional document any reviewable determination.
Send either the records or the written denial, and keep a copy of whichever you send.
Many states give residents even broader access, and federal nursing home regulations separately address a resident's right to see their records. Where those rules are more generous than HIPAA, you follow the more generous one. Ask your attorney or state association how this works in your state. This is a general overview and not legal advice.
UnityCare IT helps care providers handle the technical side of records requests: making sure the right records can be found and exported from your EHR, that only authorized staff can access them, and that copies sent electronically are protected. We offer HIPAA-aware support, sign Business Associate Agreements and work with facilities across Oklahoma, Texas and Kansas.
Security monitoring, HIPAA safeguards, backups and staff training for healthcare and small businesses.
Call or text: 405-285-3845
New customers: start@unitycareit.com
Existing customers: support@unitycareit.com
Service area: based in Edmond, Oklahoma, serving Oklahoma, Texas and Kansas
Hours: Mon–Fri 8 AM–5 PM CT; 24/7 after-hours support