When a Resident Asks to Change Something in Their Medical Record

The resident's chart says she is allergic to a medication she has never had a problem with. Or it says her son is her emergency contact when he has been estranged for years. She notices it during a care conference, tells the director of nursing, and asks for it to be fixed. What happens next is not just a courtesy. HIPAA gives residents a right to ask for amendments, and the way you respond is a process you can be asked to show.

What the amendment right covers

A resident may ask you to amend information about them in what HIPAA calls the designated record set. For a care facility, that generally means the clinical record and billing records you use to make decisions about the resident. It does not mean every scrap of paper in the building. Incident reports prepared for risk management, for example, are usually outside it, though you should confirm with counsel how your state treats them.

The request should be in writing, and you may require that, as long as you tell residents about the requirement in your Notice of Privacy Practices. A short request form at the nurses' station or in medical records makes this easy. Staff should still help a resident who cannot write easily, by writing down what they say and having them confirm it.

Accepting a request

If the correction is right, make it. Do not erase the original entry. The usual practice in a medical record is to add the amendment so that the original remains legible and the change is linked to it, with a date and the name of the person who approved it.

After that, HIPAA expects you to do three further things:

Tell the resident that the amendment was accepted.

Get the resident's agreement on who else should be told about the change, such as a physician or a pharmacy.

Make reasonable efforts to inform those people, and anyone you know has relied on the incorrect information and could be harmed by it.

The rule also expects you to act on the request within a time limit, with a limited extension available if you explain the delay in writing. Your privacy officer should know the exact timing and keep it on the request form, rather than leaving it to memory.

When you may decline

You may deny the request only for specific reasons. In plain terms:

You did not create the information, unless the person who did is no longer available to amend it.

It is not part of the designated record set.

It is information the resident would not have a right to inspect under the access rule.

It is already accurate and complete.

The last one is the reason most often used in a care setting. A clinician's assessment or a physician's judgment may differ from what the resident believes, and the resident disagreeing is not the same as the record being wrong. The director of nursing or the clinician who made the entry should look at the request before a decision is made, and the decision should be based on the record, not on irritation at being corrected.

What the written denial must contain

A denial has to be in writing and in plain language. It should include:

The reason for the denial.

A statement that the resident may submit a written statement of disagreement, and how to do so.

A statement that if the resident does not file a disagreement, they may ask that the request and the denial be included with any future disclosure of that information.

How to complain to the facility and to the federal Office for Civil Rights, with the name or title and phone number of your contact person.

Handling a statement of disagreement

If the resident files a statement, it becomes part of the record. You may write a rebuttal, and if you do, give the resident a copy. Then link everything together: the original entry, the request, the denial, the statement and any rebuttal. Whenever the disputed information is later disclosed, send those materials with it, or a summary of them.

This is where electronic records can trip you up. If your EHR does not have a way to flag a disputed entry, staff may not know to attach the statement when records are released. Ask your vendor how disputed entries are marked, and write the steps into your medical records procedure.

A short checklist for medical records

Keep a log of amendment requests with dates received, decisions and dates answered.

Route every request to the same person, usually the privacy officer.

Never alter a signed entry silently.

Keep denial letters and statements of disagreement in the chart.

Rules differ by state, and some states add their own correction procedures. Check with your attorney or state association. This is a general overview, not legal advice.

How we can help

UnityCare IT supports the systems where these requests end up: your EHR, shared folders and scanned documents. We can help you confirm that records are accessible to the right staff, that changes are tracked, and that your amendment log lives somewhere secure. We sign Business Associate Agreements and work on-site and remotely across Oklahoma, Texas and Kansas.

Related service

Security monitoring, HIPAA safeguards, backups and staff training for healthcare and small businesses.

Related articles

Keep reading

Contact UnityCare Technologies

Call or text: 405-285-3845

New customers: start@unitycareit.com

Existing customers: support@unitycareit.com

Service area: based in Edmond, Oklahoma, serving Oklahoma, Texas and Kansas

Hours: Mon–Fri 8 AM–5 PM CT; 24/7 after-hours support