Fake Records Requests: Verifying Attorneys, Insurers and Relatives

The email arrives at 4:50 on Friday afternoon from someone who says they are a paralegal. They need a resident's records "for a pending matter," the deadline is Monday, and the signature block looks official. Your records clerk wants to be helpful and is tempted to send the files and go home.

Requests for records are routine, which is exactly why fake ones work. A convincing request can come by email, fax or phone, and the person asking only has to sound like they belong.

Why these requests are hard to judge

Real attorneys, insurers and family members do ask for records, often with urgency. Fraudsters copy that tone. They count on you being busy, on pressure from a deadline, and on the feeling that refusing is rude. A name, letterhead and a fax header prove nothing, since all of them are easy to fake.

Who may receive records depends on HIPAA, state law and your own policy. The rules differ for a personal representative, a family member, a payer and a lawyer. Confirm the details with your privacy officer or counsel, and do not rely on a request's own description of its authority.

A verification routine

Use the same steps every time, whatever the pressure.

Log the request: date, how it arrived, who claims to be sending it, what they want and for whom.

Confirm the person is who they say they are by calling back at a number you find yourself, such as the law firm's number from a public directory or the insurer's number on the resident's card, not the number in the request.

Check authority. For a relative, confirm whether they are the resident's legal representative and whether you have documentation on file. For an attorney, check for a signed authorization or valid legal paperwork. For an insurer, confirm the purpose and the link to a claim you know about.

Send only the minimum needed to meet the request.

Choose the delivery method yourself, such as a secure portal or encrypted message, rather than an address supplied by the requester.

Record what you sent, to whom and who approved it.

If any step fails, pause and ask the privacy officer or administrator. A delay of a day is almost always acceptable, and a wrong release is hard to undo.

Warning signs worth a closer look

Urgency that does not allow a callback.

A request to send records to a personal email address or a new fax number.

A mismatch between the sender's email domain and the organization named.

Reluctance to provide a phone number or to be called back.

A request for far more than the stated purpose seems to need.

Language that discourages you from checking with a supervisor.

A resident who is not currently or recently in your care.

None of these proves fraud, but together they justify a second look.

Phone and in-person versions

On the phone, never confirm that someone is a resident before you have verified the caller. "I can't confirm whether anyone is here, but if you give me your information, I'll follow up through the proper channel" is a safe response. At the front desk, a relative without paperwork can be asked to wait while the right person is called.

Make it easy for staff

Post the routine at the records desk. Keep a short contact list for the privacy officer and an after-hours administrator. Remind staff that a supervisor will back them up when they slow down a request. Practice it with a pretend request once or twice a year so the steps feel normal.

Also check that records are not leaving by accident through auto-forwarding, shared inboxes or fax-to-email, since those can quietly widen who sees a request or a reply.

A word about requests from relatives

Relatives are the hardest case because they are often sincere, upset and standing right in front of you. A son asking for his mother's records may have legal authority or may not, and the front desk cannot tell by looking. Train staff to be kind and firm: thank them, explain that you need to confirm authority, and offer to have the right person follow up. Keep copies of powers of attorney and similar documents in the chart where records staff can see them, so a legitimate request can be answered quickly the next time.

How we can help

UnityCare IT can help your records team set up secure ways to deliver files, reduce the chance that a spoofed email gets through, and tighten fax and shared-inbox settings. We can also work with your privacy officer on staff awareness, with HIPAA-aware practices and a signed Business Associate Agreement in place.

Related service

Security monitoring, HIPAA safeguards, backups and staff training for healthcare and small businesses.

Related articles

Keep reading

Contact UnityCare Technologies

Call or text: 405-285-3845

New customers: start@unitycareit.com

Existing customers: support@unitycareit.com

Service area: based in Edmond, Oklahoma, serving Oklahoma, Texas and Kansas

Hours: Mon–Fri 8 AM–5 PM CT; 24/7 after-hours support