Fake Invoices From Lookalike Vendors: What AP Should Verify

The invoice looks routine. It is from the company that supplies your incontinence products, or the one that cleans your kitchen hoods, and the amount is in the usual range. The accounts payable clerk is working through a stack before the weekly check run and wants to keep moving.

Impostor invoices work because they look routine. The sender counts on the clerk comparing the invoice to a general memory of the vendor, not to the actual record. The cure is a short set of side-by-side checks.

Start by comparing against your own record

Do not compare the invoice to itself. Open the vendor's record in your accounting system, plus a previous paid invoice and the purchase order or contract. Then check each of the following.

The details that give a fake away

Sender's email address. Look at the full address, not just the display name. A swapped letter, an extra word or a different ending after the "@" is a common sign.

Vendor name and legal name. Compare spelling, punctuation and suffixes with your record.

Remit-to address and bank details. Any difference from what you have on file is a stop sign. See the callback rule for bank changes.

Invoice number. Does it follow the vendor's usual sequence? A jump, a repeat of an old number or a number format you have not seen is worth a question.

What it bills for. Does it match something you ordered, received or agreed to? Services you cannot place deserve a call.

Purchase order or reference number. Vendors you work with often reference your PO. A missing or wrong reference matters.

Amount and terms. Look for round numbers, unusual due dates or "urgent" language.

Contact details. Phone numbers and website addresses on the invoice may belong to the impostor.

Look and layout. Fonts, logo quality and the order of lines should resemble the vendor's earlier invoices. A fake may be sharper or blurrier than usual.

None of these alone proves fraud, and a real invoice may sometimes differ. Together they tell you when to pause.

Three-way matching

If your office uses it, three-way matching is the best defense: the invoice should match the purchase order and the receiving record. For a care operator, "receiving" might be the dietary manager signing off that the food order arrived, or the maintenance director confirming a repair was done. If nobody can say they received it, do not pay.

For services such as pest control, lawn care or software subscriptions, ask the department head who used the service whether they actually did.

Invoices that skip the usual path

Be careful with invoices that arrive through an unusual route: a direct message to an administrator, a text, a fax, or a note with "please process today." Route every invoice through the same intake. If a department head forwards a bill, ask them to confirm the service.

What to do when something looks off

Do not click links or open attachments you did not expect.

Do not reply to the email to ask whether it is real.

Call the vendor using a number from your own records.

Tell your supervisor, and hold the invoice.

If it is a fake, report it to your IT provider so they can block the sender and check whether others in the facility received the same message.

Keep the invoice and email as a record.

Make the check routine

A checklist that sits beside the check run takes a minute per invoice and removes the temptation to skim. Put the key checks in a short form: vendor on file, address matches, bank details unchanged, PO matched, department confirmed. Have two sets of eyes on unusual items, and set a rule that new vendors get set up only after verification.

Be clear with staff that questioning an invoice is part of the job. A clerk who holds a bill for a day is not being difficult. They may be saving the facility a payment that cannot easily be recovered.

When you have already paid

If you find the invoice was fake after payment, call your bank immediately and ask about recalling the payment. Tell your administrator and your insurer. Ask your counsel about any reporting steps.

How we can help

UnityCare IT can tune your email system to flag lookalike sender domains and external senders, and we help separate who can edit vendor records from who pays bills. We can also help you collect the verification steps into a one-page procedure for your accounts payable staff.

Related service

Security monitoring, HIPAA safeguards, backups and staff training for healthcare and small businesses.

Related articles

Keep reading

Contact UnityCare Technologies

Call or text: 405-285-3845

New customers: start@unitycareit.com

Existing customers: support@unitycareit.com

Service area: based in Edmond, Oklahoma, serving Oklahoma, Texas and Kansas

Hours: Mon–Fri 8 AM–5 PM CT; 24/7 after-hours support