Old Backup Tapes and Drives in the Closet: Keep, Read or Destroy

Someone is cleaning out the old supply room and finds a cardboard box. Inside are a dozen backup tapes, a few external hard drives and a stack of discs, none of them labeled. The box has probably been there since before the current administrator started. Nobody knows what is on it, and nobody wants to throw it away.

That hesitation is reasonable. Unlabeled media may hold resident records, employee files or financial data, which means it deserves a deliberate decision rather than a trip to the dumpster or a drawer.

Start with an inventory, not a verdict

Before choosing keep, read or destroy, find out what you have. Make a simple list:

A number written on each item, and a photo of the group.

The type: tape cartridge, external drive, optical disc, USB stick, old server drive.

Any markings, dates, handwriting or the name of the system it came from.

Where it was found and who last had responsibility for that room.

Keep the media locked up while you do this. Treat the box as if it contains protected health information until proven otherwise, because that is a safe assumption.

Ask whether it has records value

Some old backups were made for a reason: a prior EHR, a former billing system, a closed unit. Before anything is destroyed, ask:

Could this hold the only copy of any resident or financial record?

Do any records on it fall under a retention requirement for your state, payers or insurer?

Is there any open legal matter, investigation, audit or claim that could make old data relevant?

Who in leadership has authority to approve destruction?

Your records policy and your attorney decide what must be kept. Do not guess. If counsel says to hold something, hold it, and store it properly.

Find out whether it can even be read

Old media often cannot be read today. Tape formats change, drives fail, and the software that created the backup may no longer exist or may need a specific version to open it. Ask your IT provider or a data recovery specialist whether:

The device type can still be read with available equipment.

The backup software is identifiable and can be obtained.

The data may be encrypted, and whether anyone still has the key.

Reading it is worth the effort and cost compared with the likely value.

Reading old media should happen in a controlled setting, ideally by someone under a Business Associate Agreement if they might see resident data. Never plug an unknown drive into a production computer, since old media can carry malware.

If a sample is readable, you can find out what is on it and sort it into three piles: needed, duplicate of something you already have, or obsolete.

What to do with each outcome

Needed: copy the data to current, protected storage with proper backups, verify it opens, and then decide what happens to the original media.

Not readable but possibly valuable: keep it locked, note the reason in writing, and set a decision date rather than leaving it indefinitely.

Not needed or duplicated: destroy it securely and document it.

Secure destruction

Throwing media in the trash is not destruction. Deleting files from a drive does not reliably remove them either. Appropriate methods depend on the media type and typically include physical shredding or crushing, or an approved data wiping process for drives that will be reused. Use a vendor who provides a written certificate of destruction listing what was destroyed, and sign a Business Associate Agreement if your policy requires one.

Keep the certificate with your records, along with the inventory and the name of the person who authorized it. If a surveyor or insurer later asks what happened to the old backups, that paper answers the question.

Stop the closet from refilling

Once the box is resolved, set a rule: all backup media gets a label, a date, an owner and an entry in the inventory. Better yet, move away from physical media toward managed, encrypted, offsite backups so nothing ends up in a drawer again.

How we can help

UnityCare IT can help inventory legacy media, check whether it is readable in a safe environment, and move anything you still need onto protected storage. We also help arrange secure destruction with documentation, so the closet gets cleared without creating a privacy problem.

Related service

Microsoft 365, cloud storage and tested backups with access controls built in.

Related articles

Keep reading

Contact UnityCare Technologies

Call or text: 405-285-3845

New customers: start@unitycareit.com

Existing customers: support@unitycareit.com

Service area: based in Edmond, Oklahoma, serving Oklahoma, Texas and Kansas

Hours: Mon–Fri 8 AM–5 PM CT; 24/7 after-hours support